Located at 343 43rd Pl, Sea Isle City, NJ 08243, Carmen's Seafood Restaurant stands as a welcoming destination for those who appreciate the simple, honest flavors of the ocean. In a coastal town defined by its connection to the Atlantic, our restaurant serves as a gathering place where locals and visitors alike can enjoy a meal that reflects the spirit of the Jersey Shore. We believe that great seafood does not need to be complicated; it simply needs to be fresh, handled with care, and served in an environment that feels like home.
Our philosophy is rooted in the tradition of coastal dining, where the quality of the ingredients takes center stage. Whether you are looking for a place to unwind after a long day at the beach or planning a relaxed evening with friends and family, our doors are open to provide a comfortable setting. We take pride in being part of the Sea Isle City community and strive to offer a consistent, high-quality experience for every guest who walks through our doors.
What Makes Us Special
Commitment to Freshness: We prioritize sourcing high-quality seafood to ensure that every dish we serve captures the authentic taste of the sea. Our kitchen team focuses on preparation methods that highlight the natural textures and flavors of our ingredients, ensuring a satisfying meal every time.
A Welcoming Atmosphere: Our restaurant is designed to be a comfortable space where you can truly relax. We value the importance of a friendly environment, making it an ideal spot for casual lunches, family dinners, or quiet evenings spent enjoying good company and even better food.
Local Coastal Heritage: Being situated in Sea Isle City, we are deeply influenced by the local culture and the rhythm of life by the water. We aim to honor this heritage by providing a dining experience that feels authentic to the region, serving as a reliable staple for those who live here and those who visit year after year.
Dedicated Service: We believe that a great meal is defined by more than just the food on the plate. Our team is dedicated to providing attentive and genuine service, ensuring that your time with us is pleasant, smooth, and memorable from start to finish.
At Carmen's Seafood Restaurant, we understand that dining out is about more than just sustenance; it is about the experience of sharing a meal in a place that feels right. We invite you to join us at our location on 43rd Place to enjoy the bounty of the ocean in a setting that celebrates the best of Sea Isle City. We look forward to welcoming you soon and sharing our passion for quality seafood with you and your loved ones.
Whether you are a long-time resident or just passing through the area, we hope that your visit to our restaurant becomes a highlight of your time in New Jersey. We remain committed to maintaining the standards that our guests have come to expect, focusing on the simple joys of good food, a warm atmosphere, and the unique charm of our coastal home. Thank you for considering Carmen's Seafood Restaurant for your next dining occasion.
Amenities and More
Menus
Photos
Reviews Carmen's Seafood Restaurant
Jimmy Yen
21-06-2026
Food- 5/5
Service- 5/5
Ambiance- 5/5 … More
Lena Ngo
18-06-2026
This is one the best seafood restaurant we have ever been to. Not sure why they have somewhat low ratings, nonetheless everything was amazing! We finally got some big oysters (the places weve been to in philly were always small) and my crab … More
Christina Andrews
09-06-2026
I love this place. Every time i go to New Jersey, this is a must do stop on our trip. The fish is most times caught fresh and then served. From boat to table does not get any fresher than this. My faves are the flounder and the crab … More
Steffie Pinay
01-05-2026
Amazing first night dinner at this place, great view very close to the water,great valet parking. Great food and service. Better to come early or little late for dinner so you can have table available for you :) Swordfish was amazing and shrimp scallops parm. Husband and me both love it! Thank you and stay safe.
Kevin Pastine
27-01-2026
My family and I spent a few weeks at our beach house and on my father in laws birthday he wanted seafood. So we heard Carmen's was up there in reputation. So we all went, made a reservation and away we went. Seating was good inside, … More
Tony P
25-01-2026
Few experiences in life can be characterized as authentic, charming and satisfying. Without question, Carmen’s checks all three of these boxes. While you might wait 30 minutes during the peak dinner rush for a table, delicious food and … More
Bradley Childs
20-01-2026
This is our favorite breakfast spot in Sea Isle all summer long. Our first visit of the year was this past weekend and Tommy was fantastic as always. There is no better place to enjoy a meal than on the water at Carmen's! More
j d
31-10-2025
We were taken good care of by, Maddie. The restaurant and location are still so beautiful, it's been a long while since I've been here. Traveling up the coast from the ferry. … More
DJ Reese
27-10-2025
This place is the go to in Sea Isle City. New breakfast menu (havent been but heard its off the hook). We have been coming here for over 3 decades and its better each time. The staff is always friendly. They recently allowed credit cards (a … More
Jeremy Alfano
11-10-2025
Was lucky to have a work event here and was treated to some of the best seafood in the area. … More
Richard Tobak
09-10-2025
Ordered the King Crab legs, was informed by the server that they were $100, but we were celebrating and I wanted to splurge. This place being a crab house, I figured it would be a good place for king since I can't get them around me. There … More
Jeremy Alfano
05-10-2025
Was lucky to have a work event here and was treated to some of the best seafood in the area.
The crab cakes, the shrimp, and the scallops to start were phenomenal. Extremely fresh.
Everyone on my team enjoyed their meals and it was followed up with a great selection of pies. The coconut cream was out of this world.
Try the whole menu; you won’t be disappointed.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Catherine Dougherty
29-09-2025
Delicious food & excellent service. Server Delaney was very friendly and helpful! Food was quick and so good. It is right on the water, so the view is gorgeous. They stop serving breakfast at 12. All of the staff was nice & friendly and the whole place has an old school beach vibe. Great experience! More
Ashleigh Ferrell
22-09-2025
The atmosphere is ridiculously awesome! Went there for lunch on Monday, came back for dinner on Tuesday. Our waitress was Elizabeth on both visits, she is awesome! The food is excellent! I ordered the New York strip steak, rare, and it came … More
Justin Staudenmayer
14-09-2025
Wonderful restaurant right on the bay! Great food, good view and great vibes! The seafood is very fresh and the staff is very friendly!! More
Jimmy Yen
19-08-2025
Food- 5/5
Service- 5/5
Ambiance- 5/5
Drinks- NA (BYOB)
Value- 5/5
Simple unassuming dockside restaurant serving up some delicious seafood options. Carmen’s is a restaurant literally next to the dock where the kids could stare in wonderment at the many boats that were coming in and out. The restaurant itself is relatively plain and simple; wooden benches and wooden table fill the dining room (amazingly built by hand by Carmen himself) and ceiling fans fill the overhead area. There is no AC so it can get warm, but you don’t notice because of the freshness and flavors of your seafood. I got the deluxe a la Carmen platter and would go back and do it again immediately. So much delectable and fresh flavors and seafood all in one dish. It was fantastic. Everybody’s meals were great. Definitely a fantastic place for seafood and really great for those larger groups.
Order type
Dine in
Meal type
Lunch
Price per person
USD 50–100
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere: 5
Christina Snook
15-08-2025
This restaurant was highly recommended to us but we left highly disappointed. We were seated immediately on a busy Friday night but that was the only good thing about the experience! We sat for 15 minutes before our server came to take our … More
Oh Doyle
14-08-2025
Valet service and the view are nice touches, but it goes quickly downhill thereafter. Service was mediocre and the food quality was poor given the price point. Oysters had a very fishy taste like nothing I've ever had before, mussles in … More
Rsc377
18-07-2025
Went for breakfast and lunch, it was a good breakfast I got the BLT with egg. This item was over $18 and it was nothing special. For lunch I got the flounder sandwich it had a very good taste and the roll was great. In my opinion it could … More
Ron Riskie
08-07-2025
Great atmosphere! Within my 10 person party, the food was hit or miss. My "Land and Sea Parmigiana" dish was a miss. The menu described it as "a real feast." It seemed to be just a few heavily breaded scallops in marinara sauce. There … More
ReviewedByPhil
30-06-2025
Great restaurant on the waterfront! Open air, covered dining, next to a boat per. It was fun to watch boats, floating Tiki bars, kayaker, paddleboarders, etc. float by during our lunch. Not a ton of "fish" options for a seafood restaurant, … More
Brent Dockum
28-05-2025
I am saddened to share that this experience dining at Carmen's Seafood Restaurant was not as we hoped it would be. We always stay in Sea Isle for our family vacation. Exploring the beautiful island is one of our favorite things to do. We … More
Reviews Carmen's Seafood Restaurant